It has been nearly two decades since Midnight Club: Los Angeles hit consoles in 2008. For years, fans of the acclaimed street racing franchise wondered why Rockstar Games abandoned a series that was consistently improving with every release. The truth is simple and brutal: it just wasn’t Grand Theft Auto.
Former Rockstar San Diego senior designer Kris Roberts recently shared the definitive story with Insider Gaming. According to Roberts, development on Midnight Club 5 actually began, with the team actively working to build the game, which was to be set in London. Evidently, the project never graduated past the initial phases.
Rockstar Games
Internal Conflict
The cancellation came down to a sharp, internal conflict with Rockstar’s global headquarters in New York, wherein the top brass have been accused of double standards by the Midnight Club team, claiming clear favoritism for the crown jewel in Rockstar’s portfolio, the Grand Theft Auto series.
The friction started before the fourth game even launched. Midnight Club: Los Angeles missed its original early 2008 deadline, eventually being delayed further to a late October release. While the final product earned high praise and performed exceptionally well against competitors like Need for Speed, the production delay damaged the San Diego studio’s standing with corporate leadership.
The Gaming Industry and Rockstar Games
Rockstar Games
The video game industry routinely axes high quality, profitable projects in favor of those that generate a regular and robust cash flow, and Rockstar was no exception. The publisher chose to consolidate its focus on the unstoppable success of Grand Theft Auto, eventually transitioning the company’s racing-related gaming into the highly monetized GTA Online standalone product.
The death of Midnight Club 5 was not the result of poor sales or bad game design. It was a corporate casualty. A dedicated team built a phenomenal street racing experience, but in the halls of Rockstar headquarters, any project standing in the shadow of Grand Theft Auto simply could not survive.
Â
