Not a Criminal Case

Here’s something you don’t see every day. According to a report from Automotive News, a customer is suing a Honda dealership in Downtown Los Angeles, alleging the dealership filed a false police report to have officers repossess her vehicle.

The lawsuit contends the dealership illegally used police as “personal repo men” after financing for the vehicle fell through. Christine Simpson alleges she was wrongfully detained at gunpoint when Beverly Hills police pulled her over. Officers handcuffed her and held her in a patrol car for roughly two hours before determining the matter was a civil financing dispute, not a criminal theft.

What Happened?

Court filings state Simpson made a $5,000 down payment in September 2025 on a 2022 BMW X5 and took possession of the vehicle. After a lender could not be secured, she signed a second contract that allegedly gave the dealership 10 days to cancel. When the store later demanded the vehicle’s return, and she declined, the general manager allegedly threatened to report it stolen.

Police towed the SUV, and the dealership later claimed towing and repair fees. Simpson’s suit seeks compensatory and punitive damages for emotional distress, consumer law violations, unlawful conversion, and negligence. The dealership, part of Brandon Steven Motors, did not respond to requests for comment.

Repossessions Are Surging Amid Growing Auto Loan Stress

The case lands amid mounting stress in the auto finance sector. Recent reporting shows repossessions have climbed to levels exceeding those seen during the Great Recession. Higher vehicle prices and elevated interest rates have stretched affordability. Longer loan terms have amplified borrower risk. Delinquencies are rising across credit tiers.

At the same time, the repossession industry has become more technologically aggressive. Surveillance networks and license plate scanning systems have streamlined vehicle recovery. Separate data indicate buyers are taking on longer and riskier loans to afford new cars. A growing number of Americans are falling behind on payments. The financial strain creates flashpoints when deals unravel.